How To Know If An Article Is Peer Reviewed

Declan Gessel

May 16, 2024

woman working to find how to know if an article is peer reviewed

Ever wondered if the article you're reading is peer-reviewed? Using the CRAAP test is one way to find out! This test helps you determine the credibility of a source, including whether or not it's peer-reviewed.

Peer-reviewed articles have been scrutinized by professionals, ensuring that the information you're reading is trustworthy. So, let's delve into the specifics of using C.R.A.A.P. test to validate if an article is peer-reviewed.

Why Peer-Reviewed Articles Matter

woman helping a friend - how to know if an article is peer reviewed

Peer-reviewed articles undergo a rigorous quality check, ensuring the information they present is accurate, unbiased, and contributes meaningfully to a specific field of study.

Enhanced Credibility

The peer-review process involves professionals in the field scrutinizing the research methodology, data analysis, and overall findings. Published articles have earned the stamp of approval from these qualified reviewers, making them highly credible sources.

Reliable Information

The peer-review process helps identify and correct errors in research. You can be confident that the information you're basing your work on is accurate and up-to-date.

Stronger Arguments

By citing peer-reviewed articles, you demonstrate a strong foundation for your research. It showcases your ability to identify and utilize credible sources, strengthening your arguments and adding weight to your conclusions.

The Process Behind Peer Reviews

person looking at his notes - how to know if an article is peer reviewed

Peer-review is fundamental to academic publishing. It ensures quality control, enriches research, and provides a scientific lens on research. The rigorous process involves multiple stages: submission and initial screening, selection of reviewers, reviewer feedback, and revision and resubmission.

Peer-review begins when an author submits a manuscript to an academic journal, which is then screened by the journal editor. If aligned with the journal's scope and meets formatting requirements, the editor assigns the manuscript to peer reviewers specializing in the research area. These reviewers remain anonymous to the author to prevent bias.

Reviewers undertake meticulous assessment of the manuscript, evaluating its originality, methodological soundness, data analysis, writing clarity, and contribution to the field. Written feedback is then provided to the editor, outlining the research's strengths and weaknesses.

Based on reviewer feedback, the editor may accept the article with minor revisions, request revisions to address concerns, or reject the manuscript due to significant flaws or lack of contribution to the field. The peer-review process can be iterative, with authors revising their work based on reviewer comments and resubmitting for further evaluation, thereby ensuring only high-quality research is published.

Jotbot: Your Personal Document Assistant

Jotbot does AI note taking, AI video summarizing, AI citation/source finder, it writes AI outlines for essays, and even writes entire essays with Jotbot’s AI essay writer. Join 500,000+ writers, students, teams, and researchers around the world to write more, write better, and write faster with Jotbot. Write smarter, not harder with Jotbot. Start writing for free with Jotbot today — sign in with Google and get started in seconds.

What Are The Different Types Of Peer-Reviews?

woman reading an article - how to know if an article is peer reviewed

Single-Blind Review

In this model, the reviewers know the identity of the authors, but the authors remain anonymous to the reviewers. This approach can help ensure reviewers provide honest feedback without fear of retaliation. It's most commonly used in science and medical journals.

Double-Blind Review

This is the most anonymous form of peer review. Neither the reviewers nor the authors know each other's identities. This method is preferred by some researchers as it minimizes potential bias based on reputation or affiliation. It's more common in the humanities and social sciences.

Open Review

In open review, the identities of both the authors and reviewers are revealed. This approach can foster transparency and accountability but may also discourage reviewers from providing critical feedback for fear of offending the authors.

Collaborative Review

This emerging model involves reviewers working together, sometimes even directly with the authors, to improve the research. This fosters a more interactive and constructive review process.

Post-Publication Review (PPPR)

This model flips the traditional timeline. Articles are published online first, then sent out for peer review. This approach can expedite the dissemination of research findings, particularly in fast-moving fields. However, the quality of the review process can vary depending on the journal's implementation.

How To Know If An Article Is Peer Reviewed

Scrutinize the Journal Website

When determining if an article is peer-reviewed, it's essential to thoroughly review the journal's website. Most academic journals provide detailed information about their editorial policies and peer-review process on their website. By navigating to the "About" or "For Authors" sections, you can locate this information. Look for details about the use of peer reviewers and the specific review process used by the journal. This will help you confirm if the article you're examining has undergone a peer-review process.

Leverage Research Databases

To streamline your search and ensure you're accessing peer-reviewed articles, utilize research databases that cater to academic research. Many online databases offer filters that allow you to narrow down your search results to scholarly articles. Look for filters like "peer-reviewed" or "scholarly articles" to ensure that your search results include articles that have been formally reviewed. These filters can help you determine the peer-review status of the article you're evaluating.

Utilize Peer-Review Verification Tools

Resources like Ulrichsweb serve as trusted sources to verify a journal's peer-reviewed status. By searching for the journal title in Ulrichsweb, you can quickly determine if it is included in their database of peer-reviewed journals. If the journal is listed, a "refereed" icon will indicate its peer-reviewed status. This verification tool provides an additional layer of assurance when identifying peer-reviewed articles for your research.

Consult Your Librarian

Librarians are invaluable resources for navigating research databases and identifying credible sources. If you have questions or need assistance verifying the peer-reviewed status of specific articles, don't hesitate to consult your librarian. They can offer personalized guidance and recommendations to help you confirm whether an article has undergone the peer-review process.

Additional Tips

When evaluating an article, consider if the paper uses headings like "methods," "results," "discussion," and "conclusion." These headings suggest that the authors have conducted original, empirical research, indicating a scholarly article.
Look for a bibliography, works cited, or reference list. Scholarly articles will cite numerous sources, with most references pointing to other scholarly articles.
Check if the article includes charts, maps, surveys, or words like "experiment," "sample size," or "investigation" in the abstract. These elements indicate an original research study, further reinforcing the article's scholarly nature.

Jotbot is your personal document assistant. Jotbot does AI note taking, AI video summarizing, AI citation/source finder, it writes AI outlines for essays, and even writes entire essays with Jotbot’s AI essay writer. Join 500,000+ writers, students, teams, and researchers around the world to write more, write better, and write faster with Jotbot. Write smarter, not harder with Jotbot. Start writing for free with Jotbot today — sign in with Google and get started in seconds.

Points To Consider About The Different Types Of Peer Review

woman working on points to consider - how to know if an article is peer reviewed

First, there are a few different types of peer review models, and the choice of model depends on the editorial policies and disciplinary norms of the journal in question. There are pros and cons to each model: Single-blind peer review means that the reviewers know the identity of the author(s), but the author(s) don't know who reviewed their work. This model is the most common.

Double-blind review means that neither the author(s) nor the reviewers know one another's identity. Open peer review means that the author(s) and reviewers know one another's identities, and signed reviews are published along with the article. Post-publication review means that the article is published first and peer reviews are conducted later.

Each model has its strengths and weaknesses, but a well-conducted peer review process, regardless of the specific model, significantly enhances the credibility and reliability of research publications.

Write Smarter With Jotbot: Start Writing for Free Today

Jotbot is your personal document assistant. This tool can help you with AI note-taking, AI video summarizing, AI citation/source finding, it writes AI outlines for essays, and even writes entire essays with Jotbot’s AI essay writer. Join 500,000+ writers, students, teams, and researchers around the world to write more, write better, and write faster with Jotbot.

Write smarter, not harder with Jotbot. Start writing for free with Jotbot today — sign in with Google and get started in seconds.